Article written

  • on 19.01.2011
  • at 11:31 AM
  • by Christopher Wink

“They snuck in,” Northwood civic president says of Volunteers of America 16

Jan19

Disabled senior citizens were “snuck in on Christmas Eve” to a Northwood home bought in 2009 by Volunteers of America Delaware Valley, says that neighborhood’s civic association president.

“A year ago it was going to be a drug rehabilitation center and we fought it, now they’re putting the elderly in to get around the rules,” Northwood president Barry Howell told two dozen at Tuesday night’s meeting. “We’re not saying anything against the people they put in there, but we have a problem about them ignoring our deed restriction.”

The deed restriction, of course, is the decades-old Burk Deed Restriction that limits portions of Northwood real estate to remain single-family residences. It’s a zoning code add-on that has helped the neighborhood win nearly a dozen variance battles. Howell says the restriction will soon push the VOA operation at 4871 Roosevelt Blvd out, though it was partially city-funded and has government sanction as a necessary part of health services.

“Don’t let the word ‘volunteer’ fool you,” Howell said. “Don’t think for a minute that this will be good for our neighborhood.”

It’s clear that Northwood’s civic association, aided by the deed restriction, is fighting a tide of rehabilitation centers and other oft-maligned uses for big, multi-room homes in neighborhoods that have waning numbers of single families. A few residents spoke up, most to express assurance in Howell.

Howell encouraged residents to learn lessons from their neighbors.

“Look what happened in Frankford, they’d put 18 people in a two bedroom home,” Howell said, talking about that neighborhood’s battle with overcrowded recovery homes. “Don’t think it’s not about the money.”

Also at the meeting, Howell said that a previous deal with the Cancer Center of America had fallen through [YouTube video] and would be re-addressed, rumors of a dialysis center at Castor Avenue and Wingohocking Street and residents expressed concern over an abandoned property at 4712 Castor Avenue which recently had squatters.

  • Pete LaVerghetta

    VOA has a group home less than a block from my house in Cheltenham Twp. It meets all the zoning guidelines established by the township, and they have been fine and responsible neighbors.

    Northwood obviously has the law on their side and they will prevail, but I’m here to say that a group home doesn’t have to spell the end of your neighborhood.

  • Pingback: Thrifty Scott Site on Castor Avenue « The Frankford Gazette

  • Joey K

    Response to Pete: A group home does not spell the end of a neighborhood; you’re correct. It spells the beginning of the end. They decrease property values, decrease traditional single family values, and create wealthy landlords off the backs of taxpayer money. Remember when there was ONLY ONE recovery house in Frankford????? I will cruise your street and observe the VOA house on your block. I will also do a property priice comparison on the homes in your area; before and after VOA. Suburban example of the damage these properties cause; Old Croydon in Bucks County. Crime increases as well; burglaries, drugs, etc. VOA and other s like them exist to make their board members and employees money. They destroy entire neighborhoods in the guise of helping people. Look at their financials and you will see where the largest % of their money goes. When you do this you will realize they’re not volunteers; what’s in a name?

  • Joseph J. Menkevich

    “Snuck in?”

    “They” (the elderly), have every right to be here in Northwood, no matter what any of you may think to the contrary.

    COMHAR is a mental-health organization that operates an inpatient facility out of a single home in Northwood. The agency purchased a house at 5116 Oxford Ave., and placed 16 mentally ill patients there.

    COMHAR took Northwood Civic Association to Federal Court, and won.

    COMHAR, INC., et al v. NORTHWOOD CIVIC, et al
    Case Number: 2:1998cv03751
    Filed: July 20, 1998
    Court: Pennsylvania Eastern District Court
    Office: Philadelphia Office
    Presiding Judge: HONORABLE RONALD L. BUCKWALTER
    Nature of Suit: Civil Rights – Housing/Accommodations
    Cause: 42:405 Fair Housing Act

    http://dockets.justia.com/docket/pennsylvania/paedce/2:1998cv03751/97450/

    “The court held that enforcing deed restriction against a group home was impermissibly discriminatory. In finding this ruling the court discussed the argument that the enforcement of a restrictive covenant is contrary to the United States Fair Housing Act of 1988 (FHAA) This act added handicapped persons to those protected from discrimination in buying and renting facilities.”

    “Home Owners Associations often enforce restrictive covenants governing architectural control”

    “Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964- This Act provides that no person in the United States shall on the grounds of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation, be denied the benefits of,, or otherwise be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity for which the recipient receives federal financial assistance. Fair Housing Act, or Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968- This act prohibits discrimination against certain classes of people (protected classes). The protected classes are: race, color, religion, sex, national origin, disability, and familiar status. This act defines who is protected, what type of housing is covered by the law, and what types of actions constitute illegal discrimination. The requirements of the Fair Housing Act apply to housing regardless of whether or not it is developed or otherwise assisted with Federal funds. Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 – This Act provides that no qualified individual with a disability, be excluded from the participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance. American with Disabilities Act (ADA) – Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits discrimination against persons with disabilities in all programs, activities, and services of a public entity (I.e. state or local government; or department, agency, special purpose district or other instrumentality of a state, or states, or local government). The prohibitions against discrimination under Title II of the ADA are essentially the same as those in Section 504, except they apply to all programs, activities, and services of a public entity, not just those funded with Federal financial assistance. Title III of the ADA prohibits discrimination on the basis of disability in public accommodations and commercial facilities. These do not include housing, but do include the rental office of a facility (such as child care) located in the housing project that is open to the public.”

    Rep. John Taylor said Northwood Civic Association has a good track record in front of the ZBA, except for losing the fight against the COMHAR facility for mentally ill people, and he expects the success rate to continue. “We almost never lose,” he said. http://www.northeasttimes.com/2005/0127/northwood.html

    This case is closed.

    Move onto enforcing the things you actually have some control over.

    J.M.

  • Pete LaVerghetta

    joey k: I don’t think you’d be able to separate the effects of the huge decline in real estate prices due to market bubble bursting from the effects caused by the arrival of the VOA.

  • Ec1981

    A few years ago in Lawncrest this happened. The Protestant home wanted to buy a single home for some of their residents. Neighbors fought against it except the ones closest. Well the Protestant home lost and a. Developer bought the house (which the Protestant home would have kept up on) and leveled it and quickly build 5 overpriced eyesores which took forever to sell. So whats going to happen is the seniors will be kicked out and the buildig will be leveled and several buildings will be put up in it’s place or it’ll become section 8.

  • Joey K

    pete: no one is trying to seperate the effects; the facts are the neighborhood will decline with the introduction of commercial housing. This is exactly what VOA wants in order to be able to purchase more homes at discounted prices. Families will move away in droves thus forcing prices down.

    ec1981-Do you even know what or where this house is? You’re comparing apples to oranges.

    J Menk. – Thanks for your overwhelming support and optimistic outlook…..can you feel the sarcasm?

  • Joseph J. Menkevich

    ” Thanks for your overwhelming support and optimistic outlook…..can you feel the sarcasm?” – joey k

    NO – I do not. I feel ashamed for you.

    I did not write the laws, and perhaps you should pay attention to the ones I have cites and save yourself and the Northwood Civic Association any more embarrassment than has already been foisted upon yourselves.

    Last night I watched the HBO Documentary: “A President To Remember: In The Company of John F. Kennedy.” I began to cry.

    I remember JFK. I remember the Governor George Wallace of Alabama stood on National television and proclaimed that no Black/Negro students would be admitted to the University of Alabama.

    I remember that John F. Kennedy was forced to send the National Guard to Alabama so that two students would receive an education in a all White school.

    This happened in “modern America” It was not so long ago.

    I remember the Civil Rights movement and what it stands for.

    People in America have rights – even old disabled people.

    I think it is time you and the NCA remember too.

    Watch: A President To Remember: In The Company of John F. Kennedy

    http://www.hbo.com/documentaries/a-president-to-remember-in-the-company-of-john-f-kennedy/index.html

  • Joey K

    This is not the 1960′s and has nothing to do with old disabled people. It also has nothing to do with a persons ethnicity. You know me well enough that I’d be the first to help someone in need, anyone of any color, of any religion. This is about a corporation trying to diminish property values in order to create a buyers market and grow their business off the backs of hard working homeowners; of which you are one. They want the neighbors to throw their hands down and give up. As for the laws that are in place, they are not written in stone. They are always, and have always, been interpretted in different ways by many lawmakers. I agree that all people in America have rights-even old disabled people as you mentioned. Do their rights trump the rights of everyone else? I moved to this neighborhood with the intention of staying; and I don’t want this to look like many other neighborhoods that have fallen victim to greedy business people who disguise themselves as philanthropists. You know the history of many neighborhoods in the city and you know how and why they became blighted. I hope you’re not disagreeing with the majority of the neighborhood for any other reason than; you really believe this property is good for the community as a whole. If it’s just to be contradictive that would be a shame because you have too much knowledge on these issues that you could offer a lot more than a JFK documentary as an argument to allow a COMPANY to destroy your neighborhood.

  • http://www.stephen-decatur.com/ J.J.Menkevich

    “This is about a corporation trying to diminish property values in order to create a buyers market and grow their business off the backs of hard working homeowners – - -to allow a COMPANY to destroy your neighborhood.” – Joey K.

    To Joey K. -

    And your next Civic meeting is about – What?

    It’s about the Northwood Civic Association extending itself outside the boundaries of Northwood (as established in the Charter of Incorporation), by Pre-approving a Drug Re-habilitation center.
    See:
    Posted on Fri, Jan. 28, 2011, By Tom Waring
    “Howell wants the civic association’s board to consider a proposal by the Bridge to move to a 9-acre site at 1101 Adams Ave. The board will then discuss the matter with the membership at next month’s meeting. The group plans to invite Northwood Academy Charter School and the Juniata Civic Association to weigh in with their opinions. The Bridge is located at the Medical Mission Sisters property at 8400 Pine Road. It is a residential facility that provides mental health and substance abuse treatment services for 38 male adolescents. It also offers outpatient services for people of all ages.
    The facility has to move because of planned construction on the site.
    The new site would include plenty of green space and privacy, once all the debris is cleared.”

    Your organization’s president Mr. Barry Adolph Howell has no business in selling this scheme (which is outside of Northwood), but will more affect Frankford & Juniata.

    While Mr. Barry Howell thinks this is a simple matter of just taking a vote – I have received some Intelligence in the form of information – that this ploy to put a drug rehab on Adams Avenue will not only fail, but will cause the NCA some serious embarrassment (if that is even possible).

    I will wait until the Zoning Hearing to enlighten the general public, (as passing too much information into the wrong hands would not be very tactful).

    So while you speak about how the VOA ” ‘snuck in’ three disabled senior citizens,” think about what “The Bridge” will do for Northwood, Juniata & Frankford Property values:

    MinimumAge: 14 Maximum Age:
    Total Client Capacity: 
    Maximum # of Philadelphia Clients: 35
    Total # of Direct-Care Staff: 23
    Staff Turnover During Previous Calendar Year: 10
    http://www.temple.edu/prodes/adobe/TheBridge.pdf

    Grantee: Philadelphia Health Management Corp. http://www.phmc.org/site/index.php FY 2004 Funding: : $494,695

    Project Period: 09/30/2002 – 09/29/2005

    The Bridge, the only adolescent residential substance abuse treatment program in Philadelphia, will transition to a more family-based approach that takes into account the need of male adolescents ages 14 to 18 with co-occurring disorders, use the evidence-based treatment interventions, Motivational Enhancement Therapy/Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy (MET/CBT) and Family Support Network (FSN), and implement a family- and home-based continuing care program. Approximately 90 percent have co-occurring conditions. Sixty percent are court-mandated. Nearly 100 percent are on medical assistance.

    http://www.thebridgephiladelphia.org/site/

    Northwood Civic Association will meet on Tuesday, Feb. 15, at 7 p.m. at St. James Lutheran Church, at Castor Avenue and Pratt Street

  • Joey K

    Instead of getting second hand inaccurate information, you should get involved AGAIN and voice a first hand account of the facts. This way your posts will contain the whole truth and not just hostility towards Barry. Barry was called by The Bridge; he didn’t call them. The Bridge showed up at the meeting; they were not invited by Barry. Barry did not allow them to speak at the meeting and told them they would have to meet with Frankford and Juniata first; which they then did. Barry is doing a good job for the neighborhood, the whole neighborhood; and the majority of the neighborhood knows this. I didn’t live here during your tenure, but when I was looking for a neighborhood to buy a house in I read hours of articles, posts and emails from multiple sources of the antics that went on at the NCA meetings. From the few times I met you, you seem like you have a vast knowledge of the neighborhood and a passion for being active. You could probably be a lot more helpful in preventing this area from becoming a dump if you would let the past go and put your personal feelings for certain people aside. As for The Bridge it is not simply a drug rehab, if it were I would be outspoken against it. Amazing how the city has laws in place to protect us from BYOB all nude shaker bars; but will allow felons with dozens of arrests and drug habits to move in next door to families with children.

  • http://www.stephen-decatur.com/ J.J.Menkevich

    You are incorrect about me being hostile. I have been nothing but courteous to Mr. Howell, and I have been a real sweet-heart for just hushing up and letting thing go on the way they have.

    The crux of the discontinuation is the fact that the Nortwood Civic Association is operating outside it’s Charter of Incorporation by even hosting this meeting and entertaining on taking a vote on the matter.

    The Adams Avenue Property is a matter for the Frankford Civic Association to vote upon, as it is outside of Northwood’s defined boundaries as per it’s Act of Incorporation.

    It is not proper (or legally binding) to “vote” on this issue at any Northwood meeting.

    On top of it all – the Civic has not given the neighbors the proper written notification (and time) on taking a vote as per the By-laws.

    That is the Truth.

    J.M.

  • Joey K

    The by-laws do not define any boundaries; they do however state that the civic is to support, in the best interest of the neighborhood, the community that surrounds it. As for you letting things go on the way they have; you’re not a voting member are you?????? Again, if you are so passionate about helping the neighborhood; get back involved and get ALL the facts.

  • Joseph J. Menkevich

    Joey K: “The by-laws do not define any boundaries”

    - That is correct. The NCA Charter defines the Boundaries.

    The BY-Laws dictate that the NCA must give a written notice (a specific number of days prior any vote) to all members, so that they know what they are voting on.

    “As for you letting things go on the way they have; you’re not a voting member are you??????”

    You are naive to believe that being a voting member of a civic empowers someone to something.

    The NCA is a Non-Profit Corporation and must abide to the Constitution of the State of Pennsylvania, which is what gave it life.

    I have been forgiving and lenient in allowing the NCA to exist.

    I have never seen an audit of the books. There has never been one.

    I asked for one. That’s when the trouble started with the mob of dissent defectors that called themselves a BOD – now the NCA.

    The NCA is not even a legitimate Civic Association anymore.

    As a citizen of this State who has been solicited by the NCA for donations, I still am well within my rights of asking the NCA for an Audit.

    As the former president I actually thought to have the NCA be placed into receivership by the Attorney General as the NCA Illuminate had violated the Civic Association’s Charter Constitution & By-Laws, as well as the Constitution of the State of Pennsylvania.

    I did not do so – because – for the greater good of the neighborhood, I thought it was better to allow Northwood to maintain the illusion of having a Civic Association as protection than for me to expose the on-going corruption within what you now call the NCA.

    I was the last legitimate president of the NCA that served with honor & dignity – hence I am President Emeritus.

    I will always be your best critic and give you the best advise, only you are not listening.

    I really do not enjoy airing out your dirty laundry – it makes me look like your laundry boy.

    If you would like to discuss any more in private here is my e-mail: nca.president.emeritus@gmail.com

    And stop drinking the Kool Aid – haven’t you heard? It’s poison.

  • Paul Dumont

    Community residences have no effect on the value of neighboring properties.
    More than 50 studies have examined their impact on property values probably more than for any
    other small land use. Although they use a variety of methodologies, all researchers have discovered
    that group homes and halfway houses do not affect property values of even the house next door.
    They have no effect on how long it takes to sell neighboring property, including the house next
    door. They have learned that community residences are often the best maintained properties on the
    block. And they have ascertained that community residences function so much like a conventional
    family that most neighbors within one to two blocks of the home don’t even know there is a group
    home or halfway house nearby.
    For a comprehensive compilation of descriptions of over 50 of these studies, see Council of
    Planning Librarians, There Goes the Neighborhood: A Summary of Studies Addressing the Most
    Often Expressed Fears About the Effects of Group Homes on Neighborhoods in Which They Are
    Placed (CPL Bibliography No. 259, April 1990); M. Jaffe and T. Smith, Siting Group Homes for
    Developmentally Disabled Persons (Am. Plan. A. Plan. Advisory Serv. Rep. No. 397 (1986). See
    e.g., City of Lansing Planning Department, Influence of Halfway Houses and Foster Care Facilities
    Upon Property Values (monograph 1976) (found no negative impacts on selling price of houses near
    or adjacent to halfway houses for people with alcohol addictions, adult exoffenders, juvenile
    exoffenders).

  • http://tyhcefton.webs.com smurgysig

    Hello! [URL=http://fqfcefadroxon.webs.com#6438]cefadroxil sulfa[/URL] [URL=http://wwncefadroxon.webs.com#5777]cefadroxil for uti[/URL] [URL=http://jmncefadroxon.webs.com#7249]http://jmncefadroxon.webs.com[/URL] [URL=http://yiycefadroxon.webs.com#8837]buy cefadroxil online[/URL] [URL=http://ruvcefadroxon.webs.com#4492]cefadroxil gastritis[/URL] [URL=http://ssmcefadroxon.webs.com#3278]cefadroxil with alcohol[/URL] .

NEast Philly is powered by WordPress and FREEmium Theme.
developed by Dariusz Siedlecki and brought to you by FreebiesDock.com

More in Community Meetings (122 of 206 articles)