Article written

  • on 11.04.2012
  • at 09:16 AM
  • by Stacey McCarthy Realtor

Real NEastate: What's a good credit score for a renter? 4

Q: I have a house for rent in Rhawnhurst for $,1200. I have had a few people fill out applications, but nobody has been able to provide me with a credit score of 650 or above. Is this an unreasonable request? Should I lower my standards?

A: As you may know, some people are forced to rent – although they would prefer to own – because they do not meet the minimum credit score required to buy. With your qualification of a 650 credit score, you’ve actually made it harder to rent your property than to buy a home. Many mortgage lenders only require a minimum score of 620.

The odds are in your favor collecting rent from a tenant with good credit. That said, maybe there is another reason why someone’s credit score may be less than stellar. Take a look at the whole credit report, not just the score. You may end up finding a good explanation there.

Also, take your potential tenants’ earnings into account. Can they even afford the rent? Maybe an applicant with a great job now has a bad credit score now because of past credit issues that would be relevant now. And, in reverse, even a person with a great credit score can be trouble if they don’t have the money to pay the rent.

As the landlord, you are the only person who can make the determination of what type of qualifications you are willing to accept. While it’s a smart move to check the credit score of potential tenants, a credit score of 650 is a rather high standard. It may be harder to find a tenant.

Stacey McCarthy is a real estate agent with the McCarthy Group of Keller Williams. Her Real NEastate column appears every Wednesday on NEastPhilly.com. See others hereRead other NEast Philly columns here.


  • Kathy McHugh

    Great response, Stacey. There are so many legitimate reasons why some people do not have high credit scores. Landlords have to take into consideration the whole picture. I enjoy reading your column.

  • vince

    How about you sell it to a responsible buyer and stop contributing to the decline of NE Philly

  • anon

    I’m a 750+ credit score renter, and I will say I had my pick of places. Cheap and high quality were musts for me. I’m primarily renting because I expect the market to crash a bit more. If you are not one of the cheaper and higher quality places, you will not get reliable tenants.

  • Mike-Homeowner

    Please do not rent!!! Some of us enjoy owning our home. Our property values are dropping because of people renting homes. I am sick of seeing 20 people live in one house because the owner is looking to make a buck! If you must rent, do what others are doing and get a credit and criminal backround check on all tenants.

NEast Philly is powered by WordPress and FREEmium Theme.
developed by Dariusz Siedlecki and brought to you by FreebiesDock.com

More in Columns (81 of 408 articles)